How the Grand Canyon and Transportation are Connected

On our 2019 summer vacation, after spending several days in Las Vegas with the Oren’s Transit Page extended family, Mrs. OTP and I rented a car to drive to the Grand Canyon for a few more days of vacation on our own.  Our rationale was that seeing as how difficult it is to get to the Grand Canyon and that we were in the general neighborhood so to speak, we might as well take advantage of the opportunity to go since neither one of us had been there before.  We were just two of the 5,974,411 people to visit the Grand Canyon that year, but getting there is not a simple unless one lives very close to the Grand Canyon itself.  

View of the Grand Canyon, August 20, 2019

Today, about 90 percent of visitors to the Grand Canyon go to the South Rim, and we were among them.  The South Rim is about a 4 hour drive from Phoenix and about a 5 hour drive from Las Vegas.  The closest airport with commercial service to the South Rim is Flagstaff, only about 90 minutes away from the Grand Canyon by car, but service there is limited to flights to and from Phoenix. Dallas, and Denver, so most would need to connect in order to get there.  However, prior to the improvement of area roads in the 1960s, getting to the Grand Canyon was even more complicated than it is today.  

For the first half of the 20th Century, basically the only way in to and out of what is now Grand Canyon Village was by public transport of various sorts.  At first, travelers had to hire buggies or rent horses from the tour operators who set up along the South Rim starting in the 1890s in order to travel from the railroad depots at Williams, Flagstaff, or Ash Fork to the canyon.  train.  The Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway built a 64 mile long branch line from Williams in order to bring tourists to the canyon’s edge, before the area was part of the National Park System.  The line was completed in 1901.  The railway also built the El Tovar Hotel adjacent to its Grand Canyon station.  One could make a very strong argument that if it weren’t for the railroad, the critical mass needed to advocate for preserving the natural beauty of the Grand Canyon might not have been realized so quickly, and the area would not have come under the jurisdiction of the federal government in 1906 and ultimately the National Park Service in 1919.  

Grand Canyon Railway Depot

Grand Canyon Railway Depot, August 20, 2019

While the branch line to the South Rim was not used by passenger services after 1968 and freight service after 1974 until private investors and operators reinstated the service in 1989, it has become quite popular since its restoration.  There is at least one round trip each day from Williams to the South Rim, and about 25,000 passengers use the line each year.  For many years, there was an organized transfer between the Southwest Chief at the Williams Junction Amtrak Station and the Williams Depot used by the Grand Canyon Railway, though this was discontinued at the end of 2017.  

EMD F40PH 239

EMD F40PH 239 at the Grand Canyon Railway Depot, August 20, 2019

Once at the park itself, transit still plays an important role in how people get around.  The National Park Service has operated a system of shuttle bus routes along the South Rim since 1974, in order to reduce vehicular traffic within the park itself.  In fact, to get to viewpoints along the Hermit Road, one must use the shuttles at certain times of year.  The system works quite well, as the buses allow hikers who do not wish to walk along the 13 miles of the South Rim where shuttle bus service is available to use the bus for some segments instead.    

New Flyer C40LF C-10

New Flyer C40LF C-10 at Hermit’s Rest, August 20, 2019

So while the transportation at the Grand Canyon today is not a conventional public transit system, it is difficult to imagine what the Grand Canyon National Park would look like were it not for the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway bringing tourists to the South Rim in the early 20th century or the shuttle bus system that has been in operation since the 1970s.  And for those hardy travelers who wish to experience the difficulties of getting to the even more remote North Rim (where only ten percent of Grand Canyon visitors go), despite being only about 10 miles from the South Rim Visitor Center as the crow flies, it is a 225 mile, 5 hour long drive from one rim to the other.  

Photos from Vegas don’t have to stay in Vegas

The Bellagio Fountains, Paris Las Vegas, and Bally’s Las Vegas, August 15, 2019

Saying that City X is unlike any other city in the world might sound cliché, but I think there are cities that truly have a different vibe that no other city can come close to replicating.  For example, I was reminded of the grandeur of Washington, DC’s main downtown avenues and the sweeping views from the National Mall while standing on the Monumental Axis in Brasilia.  Walking through the markets of Istanbul triggered senses similar to walking through the markets in the Old City of Jerusalem.  However, Las Vegas is truly unlike any other city that I have been to on account of the many casinos and their varying architectural styles.  Just walking somewhere is a tourist activity in and of itself.

The Las Vegas transit system is also notable for several features.  Firstly, I think it is fair to say the transit system is simultaneously catering to two different markets.  There is a transit system geared towards the needs of the local population, connecting where they live to where they work and shop.  The second market is the tourist market, which relies on the transit system to get from attraction to attraction along the Strip and in the Downtown area.  There is overlap between the markets, for example, the Deuce route along the Strip is the main route in this corridor and used by both groups, but my feeling was that the RTC is catering to two distinct groups and needs simultaneously.  

Secondly, the network is notable for the amount of privately operated routes and modes over the course of the city’s history.  The privately operated Las Vegas Transit System (LVTS) was not taken over by the public RTC until the early 1990s, as LVTS was able to subsidize its residential routes by charging high fares on its route serving the Strip.  The Las Vegas Monorail is a privately owned enterprise that received no public funding for its construction or operation (though ownership was transfered to the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority after its private operator declared bankruptcy in 2020 amid the Covid-19 pandemic).  

Keeping with the city’s reputation of being unlike any other place, while it is not the only North American transit operator to use double decker buses, it is the only one I can think of that does not use them primarily on commuter routes with little turnover at each stop.  While this isn’t uncommon in places such as London, it is unusual for a North American transit property.  

Observing and photographing the system is also quite the experience.  Pedestrian crowds often make it difficult to get the types of shots I typically prefer, focusing on the vehicle and its architectural or natural surroundings.  Heavy traffic also makes it hard to set up and get shots of the vehicles with the unique casino buildings as backdrops.  Finally, nighttime photography is also challenging due to the amount of artificial light created by billboards and other illuminated displays, forcing one to “unlearn” some of the tricks usually used for those types of shots.  

I’m glad I had the opportunity to go to Las Vegas when I did, as it is fair to say a trip to the city going forward is not going to be anything like how it was when I went in August 2019 in the near future.  I do hope the city experiences a full recovery as the pandemic subsides, as tourism and entertainment are the primary workforce sectors in the city and many are likely experiencing hardship due to the lack of tourists visiting the city.  Is it high on my list of places to make a return trip to?  Probably not, as I can think of many other cities that I’d like to visit for a first time before going to Las Vegas for a second time, but I would also certainly welcome the opportunity to go back sometime if the occasion was right.  

A selection of highlights from the Las Vegas section can be seen below, or you can see all the photo galleries by clicking here.  

OTP is Finally Linked to Baltimore

With nearly 1,600 photos from the Washington, DC area, you would think this website might have had a Baltimore section by now, since the two cities are only about 40 miles apart and I grew up just outside DC.  In fact, there are more photos on this website from the Washington, DC area than anywhere other than Israel.  Yet until now, there was no Baltimore section on this site. 

There are several reasons for this that I can think of.  The first one is that typically, I’ve gone to Baltimore for Orioles games, and while one can take public transit to get to the ballpark from DC for weeknight games, there is no great public transit option to get back home.  This is also the case on weekends for both directions of travel.  And while traffic on Interstate 95 between the two cities can be abysmal at rush hour, one can get from Baltimore to the close-in DC suburbs in under an hour once the game is over on a weeknight or anytime on a weekend.  In other words, it makes sense to drive.  

Another reason is that aside from the Orioles (remember that DC did not have a baseball team from 1972 until the start of the 2005 season), I never had much of a reason to go to Baltimore.  I suppose I could have made a point of going there to check out the trains and buses, but could also just stay closer to home and explore in Montgomery County, Northern Virginia, or DC itself.  

This isn’t to say I never rode on Baltimore transit until recently.  I took the light rail once in 1999, caught a bus once to get to where the car was parked after a deluge caused an Orioles game I was at to be postponed, and I had been on MARC a handful of times.  However, one must also consider the fact that the Metro Subway did not provide Sunday service until September 2, 2001, and the light rail only operates from 11 AM to 7 PM on Sundays to this day, so in some ways the opportunities to ride these modes was limited by their hours of operation.

Recently, I’ve had more occasions to be in Baltimore, and finally had the chance to explore the Metro Subway in November 2018.  After that, I felt that there were enough photos from the Baltimore area that it finally made sense to post those, as well as any other random Baltimore transit pictures I happened to have from the past (I found some, there might be more hiding in an archive of an old hard drive I have yet to uncover).  

So now there are a total of 50 photos of transit in the Baltimore area, including the core bus service, Metro SubwayLink, and Light RailLink.  Yes, it is only a fraction of what I have in the DC section, and there are cities I’ve spent far less time in that have larger sections on this website, but it seems fitting that considering where I grew up and that I do find myself in Baltimore not infrequently, there is finally a place for its transit photos to be featured on my site.  

A selection of highlights from the Baltimore section can be seen below, or you can see all the photo galleries by clicking here.  

Rail Photo of the Month: January 2021

Silverliner V 4064Silverliner V 4064

Location: Union Station, Denver, CO
Operator of Vehicle: Regional Transit District
Date of Photo: January 24, 2020

If you follow Oren’s Transit Page on Facebook, you may recall that back in January, I posted a then and now photo comparison from Denver Union Station.  In 2014, I took the westbound California Zephyr from Denver about two weeks after the station was rededicated.  At that time, much of the surrounding area was undergoing construction projects of various sorts and the only train serving the station was the twice daily Amtrak service to Emeryville and Chicago.  Fast forward to 2020 and this area, both inside the station and out, has changed dramatically.  Many of the buildings that were under construction in 2014 around the area of the station are now complete.  RTD Commuter Rail service began in April of 2016 with the opening of the A Line to Denver International Airport.  The completed construction combined with commuter trains coming and going every few minutes (the A Line operates every 15 minutes much of the day) means that the station area, both inside the headhouse and outside of it, is much busier than it was six years ago.  It is fascinating to see how the reconstruction of the historic terminal combined with the new, majestic train hall has revitalized this part of Denver.

The RTD Commuter Rail fleet is made up entirely of Silverliner V cars, identical to those used by SEPTA.  However, there was never a plan to have a half width cab on the RTD version of these railcars, and no front facing railfan window is available, even from a few rows back (on SEPTA, the area is blocked off due to safety concerns, but one still has a semi-decent view from the first open row).  

For more photos of RTD Commuter Rail, please click here.

Bus Photo of the Month: January 2021

NovaBUS LFX Artic 5006NovaBUS LFX Artic 5006

Location: South Congress Avenue at West James Street, Austin, TX
Operator of Vehicle: Capital Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Capital Metro)
Date of Photo: January 23, 2020

I’d recommend that any visitor to Austin, Texas take some time to walk through the South Congress neighborhood.  It is an eclectic shopping district that definitely contributes to the “Keep Austin Weird” vibe promoted by small businesses in the city.  One of the attractions of the area is the unimpeded views of the Texas State Capitol building from along the length of the avenue, and for transit fans, this means it is easy to capture the Capitol building and the other parts of the downtown skyline in any photos taken in this area.  Furthermore, one of the two MetroRapid routes operated by Capital Metro serves this corridor, so the photo opportunities come frequently.  

For more photos of Capital Metro buses, please click here.

Looking Back at a Year of “Unexpected Service Disruptions”

Stretching my legs in Tuscon while riding the eastbound Sunset Limited in January 2020

As 2020 comes to an end, I think it is fair to say that little went as planned after mid-March.  That was certainly the case in my life.  This website isn’t meant to be a wide open door in to my personal life and I’m not changing that now, but I did want to share a few reflections on a year that ended up looking nothing like what I thought it would twelve months ago.  

I expected to have two big trips during 2020, and one of them took place as scheduled.  In mid-January, I flew out to Los Angeles, a good friend of mine and I took the Sunset Limited and Texas Eagle to Austin, and spent a few days there.  I then flew up to Denver where Mrs. Oren’s Transit Page and I attended a wedding.  Those were my only Amtrak and flight segments of the year.  

I had thought I’d mark a significant website anniversary in September, as I have now been running this website for 20 years!  However, there were some significant life changing events in my household each month from May through October.  Some were unexpected, and dealing with those meant whatever I could have potentially planned to commemorate this milestone had to be pushed off.  Building, maintaining, and adding to this website is truly a labor of love.  What started with about 200 photos 20 years ago now has over 11,000 photos from across the United States as well as nineteen other countries.  It has introduced me to transit fans from all over and based on email I’ve received over the years, has been a useful resource to many.

While some of the big life events in the summer and early fall months were unexpected, others were not.  Most notably, Mrs. Oren’s Transit Page and I welcomed an Oren’s Transit Page Baby (AKA Baby OTP) in to the world in May.  I never would have guessed that at age 7 months he is still waiting for his first ride on public transit, but I still hope to have that opportunity with him soon, and he comes to tolerate my hobby at a minimum should he rather not partake in it.  

Baby OTP and his father wait to photograph an approaching bus in Pittsburgh in October 2020.  Until he has agency of his own, Baby OTP will sometimes have to participate in Daddy’s hobby.  It is hoped that he continues to participate out of his own choosing as he grows older.  Photo by Mrs. Oren’s Transit Page.  

One advantage to limited travel opportunities is I did have time to get through my photo queue, which had photos in it dating back to 2017.  In addition, I also went through and created sections for some photos that were uncaptioned and unsorted for a number of years because I wasn’t sure where to place them on the website, and I now had the time to consider those decisions in a thoughtful manner.  As I write this, there are only seven (!) photos in the Uncaptioned and Unsorted Photo Gallery, whereas the number has usually had three digits for most of the past few years.  I look forward to highlighting what I’ve added to the site very soon.  

If I had some degree of confidence about how 2020 would turn out when considering the question on December 31, 2019, I can say with a high degree of certainty I have no idea what will come in 2021.  I hope to be able to travel more extensively than I did in 2020, as Baby OTP has many relatives who have yet to meet him in person.  At the very least, I hope it is safe for him to experience transit beyond his singing cuddle bus toy.  

So here’s to hoping for a less eventful 2021 for everyone!  As hard as it is for people who are likely visiting this site to do this, please avoid traveling and make safe choices (including getting vaccinated as soon as possible) so that we can go back to adventuring, seeing friends in person, and enjoying our passions to the fullest once again.

A photo of a Route 21 bus in Ithaca, NY to welcome us to 2021

Virtual Holiday Vintage Train Ride

As I wrote about in the December 2020 Bus Photo of the Month post, traditional events organized by transit agencies to mark the winter holiday season look different this year due to Covid-19 pandemic responses.  The New York Transit Museum released this video to “substitute” for offering rides on the R1-9 vintage train that typically runs along 6th Avenue on Sundays between Thanksgiving and New Year’s.

You can see my photos of these trains from past holiday vintage train runs and other special events by clicking here.  

Bus Photo of the Month: December 2020

Gillig Advantage 6325Gillig Advantage 6325

Location: Stanwix Street at Penn Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA
Operator of Vehicle: Port Authority of Allegheny County
Date of Photo: December 1, 2019

You’ve probably heard this before, but we are supposed to be preparing for a holiday season like no other this year.  However, a number of transit agencies are planning to go ahead with celebrating the Christmas season this year as they usually do or with some modifications in place.  For example, the CTA Holiday Train and CTA Holiday Bus will operate in Chicago but without passengers.  MDOT MTA’s Holiday Bus will be operating as usual, and per tradition, anyone who manages to catch it will get a free ride.  However, some traditions are on pause this year, such as the New York City Transit’s operation of its vintage train along 6th Avenue.  

In Pittsburgh, the Port Authority of Allegheny County has had a custom of decorating several buses for Christmas (and occasionally for other holidays as well), and one of those decorated buses is featured here.  The wreath and candy canes on the bike rack and the reindeer horns on the rear view mirrors aren’t the only decorations, the rear of the bus and the interior are decked out as well (see below).  However, it appears Pittsburgh’s holiday custom is among those that will not be observed this year.

Do you have any favorite holiday traditions that are observed by a specific transit agency?  Share them in the comments below.

For more photos of Port Authority of Allegheny County buses, please click here.

Rail Photo of the Month: December 2020

Bombardier 5300 SeriesBombardier 5300 Series

Location: Rhoon Station, Albrandswaard, South Holland, Netherlands
Operator of Vehicle: RET
Date of Photo: June 4, 2008

Last month, a Rotterdam Metro train made up of Bombardier 5300 Series cars such as these got quite a bit of attention in the international press.  Upon reaching the end of the line at De Akkers, the train overshot the platform and was caught by a large, plastic whale sculpture that was installed beyond the end of the elevated tracks.  Only the train operator, who was not injured in the incident, was on board the train.  Maarten Struijs, the artist who designed the sculpture, was pleasantly surprised that the nearly 20 year old sculpture was able to hold the weight of the train.

Rotterdam is a fascinating city to visit, and transit fans will be wowed by the various architectural styles found in the city’s Metro stations (in addition to the architectural styles and trends in the city itself).  I was only able to spend a few hours there in 2008, and hope to have the opportunity to go back again.  Hopefully, any trains you or I ride in Rotterdam all stay on the tracks!

For more photos of the Rotterdam Metro Bombardier 5300 Series, please click here.

Rail Photo of the Month: November 2020

Acela Express Power Car 2019Acela Express Power Car 2019

Location: Halethorpe MARC Station, Halethorpe, MD
Operator of Vehicle: Amtrak
Date of Photo: November 25, 2018

Most years, railfans look forward to Thanksgiving weekend because of all the special services Amtrak runs to take people to and from their holiday celebrations.  For example, in 2018, over 846,000 passengers used Amtrak over Thanksgiving week, and over 160,000 trips were made on the Sunday following the holiday, often Amtrak’s busiest day of the year.  Some years, Amtrak has even chartered commuter rail equipment to operate extra trains, resulting in MARC and NJTransit trains being sighted well outside of their typical territory.  And railfans gather at favorite spots along the Northeast Corridor and elsewhere in the country to see the unique and frequent Amtrak service go by.  In 2018, I spent some time on the Sunday after Thanksgiving at the Halethorpe MARC Station, just south of Baltimore, and this is one of the photos that I took while I was there.

We’ll all be able to travel again sooner if we heed the medical advice, stay home, and celebrate the holiday with loved ones over Zoom. There will be Thanksgiving week railfanning in future years instead.

For more photos of Amtrak’s Acela Express, please click here.